The Price of Productivity: When Did We Decide Other People's Trust Was Ours to Spend?
We talk a great deal about buying back our time. But what happens when the price is someone else's trust, attention and willingness to connect?
Meta's Muse seems to be all the rage at the moment. Some people won't touch it because, well, it's Meta. Others are enthusiastically embracing it, singing its praises and celebrating the prospect of having AI run their social media accounts while they get on with running their businesses and enjoying a little more time freedom.
I've had friends reach out, offering me Muse tokens and encouraging me to give it a try.
Let's be clear. I'm not anti-AI. Far from it. I use AI, recognise its enormous potential and appreciate the efficiencies it can bring. Technology and automation are incredibly useful tools. They can take repetitive tasks off our hands, streamline operations, improve productivity and give us back valuable time.
Before we declare ourselves anti-AI, let's take a look around us.
I find some of the increasingly polarised conversations around AI rather interesting.
I've seen people viciously campaign against AI, particularly when it comes to AI-generated images. I've seen users attacked and accused of destroying the planet because of the energy consumption associated with data centres. The environmental impact of AI is certainly a conversation worth having, but that's another OpEd for another day.
Here's what I find ironic.
Many of the people taking such a hardline position are already benefiting from AI and machine-learning technology every single day, often without even realising it.
Think about it.
Your email provider uses intelligent filtering systems to identify spam, phishing attempts and suspicious messages before they reach your inbox.
Your smartphone uses predictive text and intelligent correction to anticipate what you're typing, correct your spelling and adapt to the way you communicate.
Your navigation app analyses traffic patterns and real-time information to predict congestion, calculate alternative routes and adjust your estimated arrival time.
The camera on your phone may use AI-assisted computational photography to combine exposures, improve lighting, reduce noise and enhance images.
Your bank uses sophisticated machine-learning systems to identify unusual spending patterns and flag potentially fraudulent transactions.
Even some of the smart technology in our homes uses machine learning to understand routines, optimise heating and cooling and manage energy consumption.
These aren't necessarily things we consciously think of as AI. They're simply features and services we've come to rely on because they make our lives easier, safer and more efficient.
And that's precisely my point.
I'm not suggesting that everyone has to embrace every new AI application, nor am I suggesting that we shouldn't question the environmental, ethical or social implications of the technology.
We absolutely should.
But if we're going to take an uncompromising anti-AI position, we should at least be honest about how much of the technology we already benefit from.
You can choose not to use generative AI. You can object to AI-generated artwork. You can question the environmental impact of data centres. Those are legitimate positions.
But if your objection extends to AI and machine-learning technology as a whole, then consistency would require a much more fundamental rethink of how you live your life.
You'd need to reconsider your smartphone, your navigation apps, your banking security, your email filtering and a whole host of other everyday conveniences.
At some point, you'd probably need to go and live completely off the grid.
And that's fine if that's your choice.
My point isn't that everyone should use AI indiscriminately. It's that we need to move beyond the simplistic argument that AI is inherently bad or that using it somehow makes someone less authentic.
The technology isn't the problem I'm raising here. It's what we choose to do with it, and the consequences of those choices for other people.
But there's a question I've been sitting with for a while, and I think it's one we need to start asking.
Just because we can automate human connection, does that mean we should?
Here's where I have a problem.
Social media, for all its faults, was built around the idea of people connecting with people. We share thoughts, ideas, experiences, opinions and sometimes quite personal parts of our lives. We comment, respond, disagree, encourage and engage. The value is in the interaction.
Or at least, it used to be.
I've recently been engaging with someone online. I thought I was having conversations with that person. I was responding to their posts, exchanging thoughts and doing what we do on social media: being social.
Then came a post announcing that they were away on holiday and that while they were away their bot was keeping their account going so that they could enjoy their break.
Nothing wrong with going on holiday. Nothing wrong with switching off, taking a break from social media or allowing your business to operate without you being constantly available.
But here's the thing. I hadn't realised I'd been interacting with their AI.
I thought I was interacting with them.
And when I discovered the truth, I felt genuinely betrayed. I thought I was reasonably good at spotting AI-generated interactions. Generally, the telltale signs are there. But in this instance, I hadn't spotted it.
The trust was eroded.
That experience made me think about what we're actually doing when we hand over our social interactions to AI.
There's a difference between a chatbot and a human imitation
When I contact a business and encounter a chatbot, I know what I'm dealing with. I can choose to engage, ask questions and, if the chatbot can't help me, request to be transferred to a human.
That's informed consent. I understand the nature of the interaction and can decide whether I'm happy to participate.
But that's not what we're talking about here.
We're talking about AI being deliberately trained and configured to sound like a particular person, to reflect their personality, communication style and opinions, and then being deployed to engage with other people without disclosing that it's AI.
The intention is to make the interaction feel human. To make the person on the receiving end believe they're talking to the account owner.
That's not simply automating a task. That's simulating a relationship.
And there's a fundamental difference.
When I engage with you, I am investing my time, attention and thoughts because I believe there's another human being on the other side of the screen. I'm not agreeing to interact with your digital representative, nor have I been given the opportunity to decide whether I want to.
You've made that decision for me.
How is your time more valuable than mine?
This is the question I keep coming back to.
We talk about buying back our time as though that time is somehow free. But whose time are we buying back, and whose time are we consuming in the process?
The person deploying the bot saves time. They maintain the appearance of engagement, keep their account active, build visibility and potentially generate business opportunities.
Meanwhile, I am still investing my time. I'm reading, processing, thinking, responding and giving my attention to what I believe is a genuine human interaction.
My time has value too.
My attention has value too.
And I haven't consented to having either used in this way.
Social media engagement has commercial value. It can build influence, generate leads, develop business relationships and create opportunities. But when that engagement is manufactured through undisclosed AI interactions, we have to ask whether we're effectively monetising other people's attention without their knowledge.
When did my attention become yours to sell?
When the line between real and artificial starts to blur
Something else happened this morning that brought this issue into even sharper focus.
Someone reached out to me because she is genuinely struggling to distinguish what's real from what isn't online.
That concerns me.
I've interviewed many people who have been scammed online. I've heard first-hand accounts of the devastating consequences of discovering that a relationship they believed was genuine was actually fabricated. I've also come close to falling into that trap myself, recognising the warning signs just in time.
Through my show, I've had the privilege of interviewing people who were instrumental in securing legislative action in the United States against online romantic scams. A significant achievement and an important step towards protecting people from the harm caused by deceptive online relationships.
So here's the contradiction I find difficult to ignore.
We recognise the damage caused when someone is deceived into believing they're forming a genuine relationship with another person. We understand that the emotional consequences can be devastating.
Yet, at the same time, we're increasingly normalising the deliberate simulation of human interaction in the name of business efficiency.
I'm not suggesting that using an AI-managed social media account is the same as romance fraud. The intentions and circumstances can be very different. But there is a shared concern that deserves attention: what happens to trust when people cannot confidently establish whether they're interacting with a real person?
What happens when someone starts questioning their own judgement? When they wonder whether a conversation was genuine, whether someone actually cared about what they had to say, or whether the connection they thought they were building ever existed?
We shouldn't underestimate the potential psychological cost of living in an environment where human interaction can be convincingly imitated.
If we aren't careful, we're putting more than authenticity at risk. We're putting trust, emotional wellbeing and mental health into the bargain.
Technology should give us more time to be human
I have absolutely no objection to using AI to help write, organise, research, schedule, summarise or manage the administrative side of running a business.
By all means, automate the mundane.
Use technology to make your business more efficient. Give yourself the freedom to take a holiday, spend time with family or simply switch off.
But perhaps we need to reconsider the idea that every human activity is a candidate for automation.
There's a difference between using AI to facilitate human connection and using AI to simulate it.
If you don't have the time or inclination to engage with people on social media, that's perfectly fine. Take a break. Tell people you'll catch up when you're back. There's nothing wrong with being unavailable.
But why maintain the illusion that you're there when you're not?
And if you are going to have AI engage with people on your behalf, why not disclose it? At least give the other person the opportunity to decide whether they want to participate in that interaction.
We have every right to protect our time. We have every right to use technology to make our businesses more efficient and our lives easier. But we don't have an automatic right to appropriate someone else's time, attention and trust to achieve that.
So, perhaps it's time to chew on this.
Before you hand your social life over to your AI, consider:
Is your time really more valuable than the time of the people engaging with you?
Is their attention yours to monetise without their knowledge?
Is a simulated relationship an acceptable substitute for a genuine one?
And what happens to trust when we can no longer be confident that the person we're engaging with is actually there?
We can embrace technology. We can celebrate innovation. We can automate the mundane and make our businesses more efficient.
But we should be very careful about automating our humanity.
Because other people's trust shouldn't become the currency we spend to buy back our time.